Human resources at a click

A step in the right direction for gender fluidity in landmark discrimination case

Gender

Non-binary engineer, Rose Taylor had been subjected to bullying and harassment at the hands of work colleagues and faced a lack of support from management at Jaguar Land Rover. The poor treatment had started in 2017 when Taylor first identified as gender fluid/nonbinary and started changing the way she presented herself, including wearing women’s clothing. Taylor brought claims in the Employment Tribunal for harassment, direct discrimination and victimisation on the grounds of gender re-assignment. Gender re-assignment is one of the nine protected characteristics set out in the Equality Act 2010. However, it was uncertain, up until this point, whether the gender re-assignment definition would cover individuals who identified as non-binary or gender fluid.

The tribunal held however that it was “beyond any doubt” that Taylor should be protected under the gender re-assignment characteristic. Taylor’s claims for harassment, direct discrimination and victimisation were all successful on this basis. In reaching a decision, the Tribunal judge commented that it was clear that “gender is a spectrum” and that gender reassignment “concerns a personal journey and moving a gender identity away from birth sex”.

The tribunal held however that it was “beyond any doubt” that Taylor should be protected under the gender re-assignment characteristic.

The importance of this judgement is that it increases the chances of other individuals with complex gender identities falling within the definition of (and therefore under the protection of ) the gender re-assignment definition in the Equality Act 2010.

At Clarkslegal we have extensive experience of discrimination cases and would be happy to discuss any queries you may have.

Disclaimer
This information is for guidance purposes only and should not be regarded as a substitute for taking professional and legal advice. Please refer to the full General Notices on our website.

Anonymous author

Related Articles

For discrimination and detriment cases, compensation can also cover non-financial losses, which, in most cases, will include an injury to...

As we mark International Women’s Day 2025, it’s essential to reflect on the current state of gender equality in the...

We have seen a lot of disparities between younger and older people, particularly relating to working arrangements and the “digital...

Related Resources

Age discrimination factsheet

This factsheet covers types of age discrimination and its impact in the workplace. Who is protected? “Age” is one of...

Harassment counselling checklist

Checklist providing you with the tools to carry out appropriate harassment counselling. 1. Before beginning a counselling session make sure...

Managing requests for religious holidays checklist

Information checklist for managing requests for religious holiday from employees. Make sure you treat the request for holiday fairly and...

Human resources at a click